With our bare hands

8 MINUTES

In the hands of a butcher, a baker and a painter, making is an instinct

First, imagine that you are a violinist. Your hands contort around the bow, the pressure is firm, and the vibrations sear through your wrist all the way up to your elbow. Next, you are a percussionist, the snares and cymbals splatter with the energy in your fingers; the rhythm engages your whole body. Now you are a baker – you pinch and pull dough to the perfect resistance. As a painter, you smear colour across a wooden board; and, as a butcher, your hands know how to separate what will be tough from what will be tender.

In this short, the Canadian filmmaker Dan Smeby juxtaposes the work of a butcher, a baker and a painter. Despite the manual nature of each craft, they form an odd triptych. And yet, as scenes cut sharply between workrooms, and a jazz score blends with the sounds of their work, surprising connections begin to appear. Brushstrokes follow the same movement as the sharpening of knives. The whip of a painter’s cloth accompanies the thud of a cleaver through bone. As the camerawork becomes increasingly handheld and frenetic, the generative energy of creativity holds the three crafts together like a magnetic field.

A mirror-image pair of questions ties together the work of the butcher, baker, painter, and – off camera – musicians: are baking bread and preparing meat a kind of art? Or is painting and music-making a kind of sustenance? Perhaps, this film suggests, making art is as fundamental to our survival as is the preparation of food. Anthropologists have long debated the evolution of artmaking in human beings, unpicking the earliest examples of cave painting and jewellery to ask whether art is simply a nice-to-have bonus of spear-making, or whether it holds an important evolutionary purpose in its own right. Art, imbued with symbolic meaning, can strengthen the bond between kin, increasing the chance of survival.

As hands move with a confidence bordering on intuition, the film presents creativity as a kind of instinct. How do they know what to do, these hands? Of course, these craftspeople might follow a recipe, or a formula. Their work is part of a longstanding tradition. But in their deft, decisive movements, there’s also an undeniable spontaneity. Like the jazz musicians who score the film, precise technique melds with improvisation. Perhaps, in the raw impulse of individual expression, we glimpse an even deeper kind of passing-down, an inheritance across generations, even evolutionary time.

One of the first reactions to life during the COVID-19 pandemic was to take the flour from the cupboard, to get out the paintbrushes, to prepare a great dinner. It felt like the natural thing to do. We took comfort in the act of making. We felt the slow transformation of the ruminating mind into one of absorption and sometimes flow. Is the urge to make, as the runaway score suggests, about anticipation of the final results? The past year has shown many of us how having something to look forward to – something in the oven, something in the mail – can give meaning to an endless stretch of days. Is it, as another maker – the architect Charles Bello – put it, about having something to show for the life we’ve lived? Or is having something to show, as this film might wryly suggest, precisely not the point? What matters most is the making.

Written by Nicola Williams

Director: Dan Smeby

Cinematographer: Alex Balkam

Explore more

A woman drawing on an easel in a courtyard with greenery and a modern glass building in the background.

To become more attuned to the world around you, try sketching outdoors

Video by The Museum of Modern Art

Abstract drawing of a face with vibrant colours, featuring red cheeks and a patterned necklace on an orange background.
Psyche Exclusive

Born of memory and mystery – the otherworldly works of a self-taught, unhoused artist

Directed by Tal Amiran

Photo of a hand using a black marker to redact text on paper several words are boxed to be emphasised.
POETRY

Reignite your creative fire with blackout poetry – the art of framing what’s already there

Directed by Andrew Lavers

An Aboriginal painter depicts scenes from her youth in this beautiful short

A film by Grace Kemarre Robinya and Jonathan Daw

Surreal photo of a person wearing glasses and a hat with their face distorted, leaning towards a camera in a hallway.

This sculptor finds deep weirdness – not divinity – in the human form

Directed by Ben Berman

An elderly woman in a patterned beanie holding a red card with holes punched into it in front of her face.

Circles possess a defiant beauty in the abstract works of Howardena Pindell

Directed by César Martínez Barba

Close-up of hands holding clear frogspawn with visible black eggs in a natural outdoor setting.
Psyche Exclusive

A filmmaker’s never-realised ideas become an exploration of self-doubt

Directed by Cameron Nicoll

A woman holds a square mirror that blocks her face; it reflects rocks and grass. There is blue sky and clouds in the background. The only element in focus is the reflection on the mirror.

Losing her eyesight, a painter’s art evolves with the way she sees the world

Directed by Liberty Smith