Morality TV

8 MINUTES

Why are we so drawn to characters that take us to moral extremes?

If your algorithmic menu of streaming options overflows with charismatic sociopaths, sympathetic murderers and thugs you can’t help but root for, you’re not alone. Recent research from Jordan Wylie, an assistant professor of psychology at Cornell University, and Ana Gantman, an associate professor of psychology at Brooklyn College and the CUNY Graduate Center, indicates that audiences prefer spending time with morally ambiguous and immoral characters, even though they find it more challenging than watching morally good ones. Given that most people exist somewhere near the moral middle, what’s the psychological appeal of venturing to the far-flung extremes of human behaviour? Adapted from a Psyche Idea by Wylie and Gantman, this original video essay draws on Breaking Bad, The Sopranos, Game of Thrones and more to explore why people are so eager to challenge themselves by spending hours with characters who navigate moral terrain most of us will never encounter.

Producers: Adam D’Arpino, Namir Khaliq

Associate producer: Tamur Qutab

Narrator: Alice Marks

Explore more

Photo of a man with a serious expression sitting at a table holding a fork in a kitchen setting.

What is it about film and TV antiheroes that’s so captivating?

They’re entertaining, of course – but research highlights a deeper psychological reason viewers are drawn to the bad guys

by Ana Gantman & Jordan Wylie

A fictional character with pale skin and no nose looks up in a dim, atmospheric setting, photo from a film scene.

Immersion in fictional worlds allows us to own our dark side

Our liking for fictional villains such as Voldemort tells us something about the dark side of our own personalities

by Rebecca Krause-Galoni

Photo of a chain-link fence with a “Private Property No Trespassing” sign in front of an open field.

Your sense of right and wrong is interwoven with your personality

Personality traits such as agreeableness and openness to experience can help explain differences in moral judgment

by Luke D Smillie & Milan Andrejević

Black and white portrait photo of an older man with curly hair and deep-set eyes, looking intently to the left.

How to create compelling characters

It’s not only writer’s intuition. Use personality psychology to create just the right blend of surprise and believability

by Kira-Anne Pelican

A vintage voltmeter displaying a scale in volts and ampères with a brass base and needle indicator.

What a real-life ‘trolley problem’ reveals about morality

We used an electric-shock dilemma to test the strength of people’s moral principles when faced with real-world complexities

by Dries Bostyn

A busy street with billboards, people walking and police officers beside an overturned green auto-rickshaw, with a blue bus and other vehicles passing by.

What the ‘fundamental attribution error’ misses about blame

Classic research says we overlook situational factors in explaining people’s misdeeds. But the reality is more complex

by Laura Niemi, Jesse Graham & John M Doris

Photo of a woman with curly hair comforting an injured woman in a crowd, whose nose is bleeding.

Fiction has a special power to give us insight into our flaws

Losing yourself in a book, film or show provides a useful mirror for character – one that is hard to access in real life

by Martina Orlandi

A film still of a woman, Katniss Everdeen from The Hunger Games movie franchise, with a braid standing in a transparent elevator looking out with a thoughtful expression.
FILM

Hollywood’s fixation on the wrong stories won’t help our world

Today’s global problems are caused by broken systems, but the studios still feed us a diet of movies focused on individuals

by Namir Khaliq