Erich Fromm on mental health

17 MINUTES

Can an entire society be mentally ill? A perspective from 1960

‘Most people forget themselves.’

Huston Smith (1919-2016) was one of the preeminent US scholars of religion and comparative philosophy during the 20th century. His distinguished career, which included serving as professor of philosophy at MIT from 1958 to 1973, also comprised stints as a presenter on public access television, creating a series of programmes that interrogated questions of spirituality, meaning and belief. Among these was The Search for America (1959-60), in which Huston interviewed prominent thinkers to discover ‘moral answers to 16 of the most basic public and private issues that Americans face’.

In this excerpt from an episode centred on mental health, Smith has a wide-ranging discussion with the social psychologist, psychoanalyst and philosopher Erich Fromm (1900-80), a German Jew who fled Nazism and resettled in the US in 1934. Discussing what he perceives as the ills of American society – namely alienation, conformity, consumerism and the looming prospect of nuclear annihilation – Fromm questions whether the establishments of psychology and psychiatry are truly concerned with wellbeing, or merely with making people adjust to an ‘insane’ system. While some aspects of the discussion are best understood as a snapshot in time, others seem prescient – in particular, his view that a consumerist society offers countless escapes from reality yet leaves many ever dissatisfied, unable to cultivate a deeper wellbeing.

Video by The Search for America

Explore more

Photo of a young caregiver in a mask and an elderly woman smiling warmly, leaning towards each other in a cosy setting.

Our age of crises needs Bollnow’s philosophy of hope

What if life crises are not pitfalls en route to Maslow’s self-actualisation but hopeful new beginnings, as Bollnow argued?

by Norm Friesen

A person watering plants in an urban garden with buildings in the background on a cloudy day.

How to make your life feel more meaningful

Existential psychology offers specific ways to find meaning, giving you a buffer against despair in these anxious times

by Steven Heine

Stained glass artwork depicting two figures in medieval attire, one seated and sleeping, the other standing, on a blue background.

William James was right about our strange inner experiences

Rather than Freud’s cynicism or Jung’s enthusiasm, we need an inquisitive approach to unusual forms of consciousness

by David Yaden

Painting of a courtyard with multiple windows, mostly closed, and one open window letting light into a shadowy corner.

How to be anxious

Anxiety might be uncomfortable, but with a philosophical approach you’ll find it can awaken a thrilling sense of freedom

by David Egan

Photo of two empty swings by a lake, cordoned off with yellow caution tape against a cloudy sky.

Existential psychotherapy helped my students cope with chaos

By facing the terrifying truths of existence, we become stronger, more resilient and more able to take control of our lives

by Ronald Chau

Photo of a tattooed barber trimming a man’s hair in a striped cape, with a reflection in the mirror.

When your authenticity is an act, something’s gone wrong

Authenticity has changed from an inward gaze to a social display. Can we reconcile the performance with the real thing?

by Joseph E Davis

Photo of a person sitting in a train gazing out a window at blurred trees under sunlight.

The question therapy doesn’t answer: who are we really, really?

Therapy is a valuable tool for self-understanding. But spiritual practices can unlock a more expansive view of the self

by Eric Jannazzo

Illustration of a nurse pouring a drink for a seated man at a table with flowers and a book.

What we lose by being overly scientific about healthcare

Empirical studies tell us about treatment outcomes, but they overlook the cultural dynamics that can help us feel better

by Ana Todorović