Erich Fromm on mental health

17 MINUTES

Can an entire society be mentally ill? A perspective from 1960

‘Most people forget themselves.’

Huston Smith (1919-2016) was one of the preeminent US scholars of religion and comparative philosophy during the 20th century. His distinguished career, which included serving as professor of philosophy at MIT from 1958 to 1973, also comprised stints as a presenter on public access television, creating a series of programmes that interrogated questions of spirituality, meaning and belief. Among these was The Search for America (1959-60), in which Huston interviewed prominent thinkers to discover ‘moral answers to 16 of the most basic public and private issues that Americans face’.

In this excerpt from an episode centred on mental health, Smith has a wide-ranging discussion with the social psychologist, psychoanalyst and philosopher Erich Fromm (1900-80), a German Jew who fled Nazism and resettled in the US in 1934. Discussing what he perceives as the ills of American society – namely alienation, conformity, consumerism and the looming prospect of nuclear annihilation – Fromm questions whether the establishments of psychology and psychiatry are truly concerned with wellbeing, or merely with making people adjust to an ‘insane’ system. While some aspects of the discussion are best understood as a snapshot in time, others seem prescient – in particular, his view that a consumerist society offers countless escapes from reality yet leaves many ever dissatisfied, unable to cultivate a deeper wellbeing.

Video by The Search for America

Explore more

Illustration of a colourful green and red parrot perched on a branch, against a plain beige background.

What I found in one of the tiniest languages

The great complexity and extraordinary simplicity of a constructed language with no more than 140 words

by Hannah H Kim

A bronze statue of a girl facing a large bull sculpture on a cobblestone street in an urban setting.

True courage isn’t being fearless, it’s fearing well

Aristotle created the blueprint for the bravery we need to resist injustice and do the right thing, even at our own risk

by Andrew Culbreth

A painting on a wall with a man in a suit standing in profile beside a doorway in an art gallery.

Embrace the monotony

A museum guard’s tale of long, slow hours on the job changed how I think about seemingly empty stretches of time

by Hannah Seo

Photo of a man holding laundry in a dimly lit room with shelves, a microwave and a curtain on the left.

What do Japan’s hikikomori reveal about our lonely world?

Unemployed and isolated, the residents of a hikikomori rehab centre hold up a mirror to a society that’s failing them

by Alain Julian

Sketch of a woman in historic attire with hands clasped, head bowed, drawn on gridded paper.

For the Puritans, embracing God’s will could get dangerous

The group at the heart of American origin stories had a complex relationship with despair – and a need to reckon with it

by Alexandra M Lord

A switched-off smartphone on a bright yellow surface with fingerprints and smudges on the black screen.

A brief escape from social media

After leaving my phone behind for a week and coming back to it, I saw my social media use in a stark new light

by Tamur Qutab

Aerial photo of Würzburg, a European cityscape with historic buildings, church spires and a clock tower under a partly cloudy sky.
TRAVEL

Why ‘false authenticity’ is so unsettling

The Old Town of Würzburg seemed to offer a real connection to the past. But none of it was authentic

by Sam Dresser

An elderly man seated on a city street as skateboarders perform tricks around him.

Where are you on the ‘happiness curve’?

When I came across the U-shaped happiness curve, I knew I had to act if I wanted to buck the midlife average

by Richard Fisher