Alison Gopnik: cognition, care and spirituality

7 MINUTES

Humans are uniquely reliant on caregivers. This isn’t a weakness, but a wondrous gift

Humans often fancy themselves quite extraordinary specimens in the animal kingdom. But while most recent research undermines our centuries-long claims of human exceptionalism, there are some ways in which we are quite unique – especially when it comes to childhood and childcare. Indeed, even when compared with our closest primate relatives, humans spend a truly inordinate amount of time – roughly 15 years at the beginning and the end of the lifespan – as vulnerable creatures, not reproducing, and largely dependent on others.

In this Aeon Original animation first published in 2021, Alison Gopnik, a writer and a professor of psychology and affiliate professor of philosophy at the University of California at Berkeley, examines how these unparalleled vulnerable periods are likely to be at least somewhat responsible for our smarts. Exploring how different brain states accompany different life stages, Gopnik also makes a case that caring for the vulnerable, rather than ivory-tower philosophising, puts us in touch with our deepest humanity.

Director: Léon Moh-Cah

Interviewer: Sally Davies

Producer: Kellen Quinn

Animators: Léon Moh-Cah, Matei Monoranu, Andi Concha

Interview audio editor: Chloe Abrahams

Sound designer: Matt Part

Explore more

Photo of an adult chimpanzee sitting with a young chimp in a forest setting with dappled sunlight in the background.

Chimpanzees correct cultural biases about how good mothers behave

A philosopher observes chimpanzee mothers and their infants interact, realising how cultural our ideals of motherhood are

by Maria Botero

Photo of a chick facing a blue screen with white squares arranged randomly, resembling stars in the sky.

Babies and chicks help solve one of psychology’s oldest puzzles

From the beginning of life, both humans and other species can grasp important characteristics of the world around them

by Giorgio Vallortigara

Ivory sculpture of a lion-human figure shown from three angles on a black background.

Our greatest invention was the invention of invention itself

Hypothetical thinking is the key to sustained innovation and creativity: invention drove the evolution of the human mind

by Keith Frankish

Photo of people silhouetted against a blue aquarium tank watching a beluga whale swim towards them.

Human exceptionalism imposes horrible costs on other animals

We owe it to other animals and to ourselves to resist human exceptionalism. Accepting their inner lives is the first step

by Barbara J King

Photo of a green hummingbird with a red bill in flight against a blurred green background.

A vast, thrilling world of nature unfolds outside of human time

Human life might stretch over decades, but the lifespans of many other organisms on this pale blue dot leave us in the dust

by Nicholas P Money

Photo of two people sitting on a rock by a stream surrounded by greenery, one with an arm around the other.

Rewilding attachment theory by recognising Earth as a caregiver

We are raised by people, but we are also raised by the Earth – here’s what that means for our emotional development

by Vanessa Chakour

Photo of an older woman in a straw hat holding a doll in a park with another person embracing her from behind.
AGEING

The radical impact of seeing Alzheimer’s as a second childhood

Even if the retrogenesis model isn’t strictly true, seeing Alzheimer’s as a second childhood impacts radically on patient care

by Han Yu

A wooden box filled with vintage black-and-white photos, some faded, shown in an artistic photograph.

I’m childfree by choice. Should I feel guilty about ending my line?

My uterus is not my ancestors’ vessel for future progeny. What’s the impact of my choice on my family’s genetic lineage?

by Starre Vartan